Defense attorneys say APS cheating scandal evidence 'tainted'

Defense attorneys say APS cheating scandal evidence 'tainted'

Posted: Updated:
ATLANTA -

Defense attorneys in the Atlanta Public Schools cheating case say state investigators pressured educators to get information.

Attorney Brian Steel, who represents former Kennedy Middle School Principal Dr. Lucious Brown, said that former Superintendent Beverly Hall issued an ultimatum ordering employees to talk or face losing their jobs. Steel said that order should force the judge to throw out the 65-count cheating indictment.  Hall's attorney has joined Steel on the issue. The defense attorneys contend all the testimony in the state report by investigators Mike Bowers and Bob Wilson was coerced.

"One commentator has stated that if the tainted evidence was presented to the grand jury, the indictment will be dismissed," Steel said. "When tainted evidence is introduced at trail, the defendant is entitled to a new trial."

Steel says Bowers and investigators Wilson and Richard Hyde illegally wore two hats: one hat to compel teachers to cooperate with the cheating investigation, and a second hat to help prosecute criminal charges against the same educators.

Bowers says the cheating scandal is the worst mess he has seen in 40 years. Bowers admonished Steel for misinterpreting Fulton County District Attorney Paul Howard's role.

"He didn't get involved at all. Period," Bowers said.

Also on Monday, the judge ruled Howard's office can remain on the case. Another defense attorney had asked the court to remove Howard because she believed his wife was too close the case.

  • More Local NewsMore>>

  • Manchester High evacuated over 'text message' bomb threat

    Manchester High evacuated over 'text message' bomb threat

    Wednesday, April 23 2014 12:36 PM EDT2014-04-23 16:36:51 GMT
    Students at Manchester High School were evacuated from the building late Wednesday morning following a reported bomb threat.
    Students at Manchester High School were evacuated from the building late Wednesday morning following a reported bomb threat.
  • Use of force 'not justified' in officer shooting of Bartow teen

    Use of force 'not justified' in officer shooting of Bartow teen

    Wednesday, April 23 2014 11:20 AM EDT2014-04-23 15:20:30 GMT
    A Bartow County Grand Jury has stated that the use of deadly force in the February shooting of a teen was 'not justified'. Christopher Roupe, 17, was fatally shot by Euharlee officer who claimed the teen answered the door with a gun.
    A Bartow County Grand Jury has stated that the use of deadly force in the February shooting of a teen was 'not justified'. Christopher Roupe, 17, was fatally shot by Euharlee officer who claimed the teen answered the door with a gun.
  • Man back in jail on rape charges after previous peeping tom arrest

    Man back in jail on rape charges after previous peeping tom arrest

    Wednesday, April 23 2014 8:28 AM EDT2014-04-23 12:28:00 GMT
    Cobb Police say a young Kennesaw man, who was arrested earlier this month on trespassing and felony peeping tom charges, sexually forced himself on a young woman last week.
    Cobb Police say a young Kennesaw man, who was arrested earlier this month on trespassing and felony peeping tom charges, sexually forced himself on a young woman last week.
Powered by WorldNow

WDCA My20 & my20dc.com
5151 Wisconsin Ave NW
Washington, DC 20016

Phone: (202) 244-5151
Email Us

Didn't find what you were looking for?
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 Fox Television Stations, Inc. and Worldnow. All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Ad Choices